Difference between revisions of "Talk:Artificial nourishment"
(Comments added as part of review) |
Dronkers J (talk | contribs) |
||
| Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
| + | ==Review by Dominic Reeve (January 2013)== | ||
| + | |||
| + | |||
The existing text provides a helpful introduction to the subject. It reads well and is of an appropriate length and detail. My only quibbles would be that given the amount of work in the area more references should be provided. Also, there is no discussion of some of the practical issues that can arise (some are discussed in Reeve et al 2012). Additionally, an excellent presentation of theory, methods, techniques and case studies has been published by CIRIA (2010). | The existing text provides a helpful introduction to the subject. It reads well and is of an appropriate length and detail. My only quibbles would be that given the amount of work in the area more references should be provided. Also, there is no discussion of some of the practical issues that can arise (some are discussed in Reeve et al 2012). Additionally, an excellent presentation of theory, methods, techniques and case studies has been published by CIRIA (2010). | ||
Typographical points: | Typographical points: | ||
Revision as of 22:21, 31 January 2013
Review by Dominic Reeve (January 2013)
The existing text provides a helpful introduction to the subject. It reads well and is of an appropriate length and detail. My only quibbles would be that given the amount of work in the area more references should be provided. Also, there is no discussion of some of the practical issues that can arise (some are discussed in Reeve et al 2012). Additionally, an excellent presentation of theory, methods, techniques and case studies has been published by CIRIA (2010). Typographical points: To carry out an artificial nourishment project, various methods can be applied; see e.g. xxxx) – include references This phenomenon, however, is a well-known coastal feature; one cannot ‘unpunished’ create a disturbance in the coastal zone. – Ambiguous English. Suggest ‘This phenomenon, however, is a well-known coastal feature; one cannot create a disturbance in the coastal zone without some recompense.’
References: CIRIA, 2010. Beach Management Manual, 2nd Edition, Publication no. RP787, London Reeve D E, Chadwick, A. C. & Fleming, C.A., 2012. Coastal Engineering: Processes, Theory and Design Practice, 2nd Edition, SPON Press, 514p
